Monday

Golf Meets Glamour - Is TIME Pandering for Readers?

.















That's how it looks to me.

In what appears to be a desperate attempt to reel in readers, a story appeared last week on TIME.com with the titillating title, "Lady Golfers for Rent: Escort Service for Duffers?" They say a good title is an important part of link baiting, and this lascivious lure certainly seems to fit that bill.

The blatant link baiting however, doesn't bother me... as long as a story is well written, accurate and engaging I have no problem with a couple of calculated keywords in its title. However, when the story underneath the title is poorly researched, exploitative and bordering on the slanderous, I take issue. And that's what it comes down to with the TIME article. In the TIME piece, Sean Gregory, writes about Play Golf Designs, the Las Vegas-based company of former Futures Tour player Nisha Sadekar.

PGD offers custom golf event planning and entertainment services to nonprofits, charities, corporations, and private groups. They act as a full service golf travel agency, booking the perfect accommodations, reserving the tee times you want at the courses you choose, and securing tickets to the most sought after Las Vegas shows.

You'd hardly know this from reading Mr. Gregory's article though, because he chose to focus on PGD's golf entertainment services, and proceeded to sex up the story so as to leave readers with the impression that something naughty and nefarious was going on.

In fact, Play Golf Designs works with a team of golfers, each with professional golf tour experience. These PGD Professionals will conduct golf clinics or animate team building exercises... they'll challenge your group to a closest-to-the-pin or power driving competition. This is the type of Golf Entertainment PGD offers. Their PGD Professionals are some of the best players in the world, each having played on the LPGA Tour, Ladies European Tour or Futures Tour. These are damn good golfers. Each one is also a beautiful woman and that, I feel, is where Sean Gregory found the fodder for his post. He, like many, realizes that where the male dominated world of golf meets glamorous feminine beauty is a very buzzworthy intersection.

Barely touching upon the golf expertise of the PGD golfers, Mr. Gregory preferred instead to fill his post with references to "buddies during a bachelor party", "substantial fees" and (my favorite) "shorts shorter than a tap-in putt".

I happen to know Nisha Sadekar. I've written about her as a fellow golf blogger and I speak to her quite regularly. We've also met on a couple of occasions in New York. She's the consummate professional and extremely dedicated to her business. She's also passionate about golf, as are the women she works with. And, they all have tremendous respect for the LPGA players. Nisha told me that what bothered her most about Sean Gregory's story was that by pulling her quotes out of context he had presented her as dismissive towards Lorena Ochoa, a player she clearly admires.

Mr. Gregory didn't attend a Play Golf Designs event nor apparently did he speak to anyone who has attended one. Had he done so... like I did... I don't think his story would have had the same lugubrious edge. Ryan Ballengee, writing on his popular and respected golf blog, Waggle Room, called the TIME piece "an extremely unfortunate example of lazy journalism and corporate hypocrisy".

We all know that journalism is in a state of crisis right now; facing declining readership and falling ad sales. I tend to think the sensationalism in this article was simply an attempt by Mr. Gregory... and/or TIME... to counteract that trend. However, the disregard he shown for Nisha Sadekar and the business she's spent years building, was careless and unprofessional.

"Golf Meets Glamour" Photograph: © Golf Girl Media

20 comments:

  1. Sean Gregory is a perfect example of a lazy,exploitative, un-informed,wanker. He should get his ass chewed out by the folks at Time, but will instead probably get promoted for driving traffic to their site. Now, if those boys with the pliers and blowtorch ever find him....

    ReplyDelete
  2. These days when a news magazine writes about "ladies for rent" and throws in the word "escort service" the story is pretty much guaranteed to attract eyeballs. And golf to the mix and it's probably the most effective headline a news magazine could come up with. That they don't care that Nisha (and the women who work with her) are hurt by it doesn't surprise me. As you point out, these days there's a lot of desperation in media circles.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It bothers me when men try to protect women from "being objectified", especially because those same men are usually silent about the issue of women getting paid less than men for equal work.

    If anyone looks at the Play Golf Designs website and actually takes the time to read about what they stand for and what they provide they'll see the TIME article for the obvious link bait it is.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love the photo of the Golf shoe/Chanel shoe. Very clever.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Pure desperation! maybe because no one woman would even look at him at the golf course!

    You know what, I'm flabbergasted, appalled by what he wrote! he just can't take the idea that women finally broke in the sports...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Good for you for calling Time/him out.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I just returned Time's job offer to be their golf editor to them.

    I have principles. And I never lie.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The guy never stops impressing me.

    How was One-Eyed able to post a comment with his pants on fire like that?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Talk about Time's a'wasting.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I now think Sean Gregory is a lazy horses-ass. Anyone who writes for a living and does not do their research/homework deserves whatever backlash they get.

    Here's my suggestion ladies: the world of print is hurting so I say take your Time magazines and put them in the trash, do not renew. If the power of the purse is all they will understand, show them your opinion counts. If Time wants your business, let them earn it!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Time magazine is but a shadow of its former self. Though I hate to admit it, I remember well the days before the internet when a mention in Time dedicated itself to hard news and had maybe one or two small features a week on popular culture. But that was a different time. Nowadays in order to compete they've become a pop culture/celebrity magazine.

    Time's list of The World's Most Influential People is becoming increasing similar to People Magazine's list of The World's Most Beautiful People.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Patricia,

    I would recommend that you send this article to Time using either your media contacts or as a last resort, a letter to the editor.

    I know whom I trust in this issue and it is not the sensationalistic journalist, it is you, the person who knows the subject of the article well and the one who has a reputation for calling it like it is.

    Time is not pandering for readers, they are assassinating the good character of someone by making them look like someone/something they aren't and it is utterly ridiculous that they can do so without compunction or remorse. This is not journalism.

    If I sound angry, I'm sorry, it is because I am.

    ReplyDelete
  13. When the stupid Time article came out Anna Rawson was still on the PGD roster (they even had a screenshot with her accompanying the article). Now she is gone from the website. Coincidence or not?

    ReplyDelete
  14. I agree with golf growl to the extent that the language (the headline in particular) was intentionally provocative. Of course, you all read the article, so by that most basic of measure, Mr. Gregory did his job.

    Maybe the writing is lazy, and irresponsible in the sense that Mr.Gregory didn't explicitly state "PDG does not sell sex", but let's be honest here, PDG is most certainly selling the illusion of sex. To think anything different borders on delusion. PDG didn't end up with a stable of beautiful women by accident. Admittedly the act and illusion are very different things.

    My take is that Mr.Gregory had very little to say himself. He basically intertwined his own innuendo between the divergent quotes of Nisha Sadekar and Dr. Lopiano. Object to the innuendo if you like, but in all likelihood, PGD wouldn't be successful without it. Guys like to flirt with pretty girls, and even when we know it's not happening, there's always the optimistic whisper in the back of our heads that says "maybe, just maybe...". I think it's a great business model, and wish Ms. Sadekar nothing but success. It's positively awesome that there's an opportunity for female golfers (especially with Tour opportunities in decline) to earn a living in a golf-related field, but again, talent isn't what's making the money.

    As to what ashgolf said...more often than not, it's women who feel compelled to protect other women from being objectified. It's also quite often double-speak for "I can't make a living off my looks, why should she". Personally, I think it's up to the individual (male or female) to decide if/when he/she is being objectified. Who am I to say what's right for another?

    Finally, to Patricia's point that Nisha was quoted out of context; I'm willing to accept that Mr. Gregory probably didn't frame her words as she envisioned, but there's a huge difference between mis-quoted, and quoted out of context; the latter usually a euphemism for "I said some stuff I wish I hadn't".

    ReplyDelete
  15. I personally don't like being objectified.

    I much prefer safe sex.

    ReplyDelete
  16. On the objectification question I understand exactly what Ashley is saying and I don't agree with Qwow that women are more likely to complain about women being objectified. I feel men are just as likely if not more so. Though I do agree with the reason he gives, the "I can't make a living off my looks, why should she" is often the declared motivation for men and unattractive women to try to "protect attractive women from objectification".

    I also agree that "it's up to the individual (male or female) to decide if/when he/she is being objectified".

    ReplyDelete
  17. Whether women are being objectified or not, there is very little separating the APPEARANCE of the PGD site from an escort service. That's an objective opinion. I actually think it's a brilliant idea, but just don't see how anyone can argue the point. The site is selling the sexiness of these golfers as a main attraction to their service.

    Fine by me. But acting indignant rings a little hollow.

    ReplyDelete
  18. A smorgasbord of opinions and thoughts. I thought it was shoddy & irresponsible journalism (if you can really call it journalism). Where does (or will) TIME draw the line? What happened to checking one's story? Indeed, journalism is dying when standards are lowered to make a buck. Shameful, really.

    Excellent post Patricia!

    ReplyDelete
  19. i will not even read the story. or go to the site. i am tired of all these peoples opinions. prefer to pretend these people don't exist.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Welcome to mysurbuy.com:

    Your first choice for Discount golf clubs.

    We have the best Quality and Service, BUT the Lowest price in the industry. We provide very competitive wholesale prices to our resellers who aim to develop their business. Most of our products on website are already listed with discounts corresponding to your membership grade.

    We deal with quality OEM products from various suppliers around the world or directly from the factory in Asia /Hong Kong /China.

    Welcome to join us, hopefully we can establish the business relationship with mutual benefits. We will highly appreciate for your close attention for our business, and your 100% satisfaction is our goal.

    Please check our website [url=http://www.mysurbuy.com]Discount golf clubs[/url] , and if any further needs, please feel free contact us : support@mysurbuy.com

    Callaway Lady's X-22 Irons Set
    2009 Taylormade Burner Irons
    TaylorMade R7 SuperQuad Driver
    TaylorMade R7 CGB MAX Driver
    TaylorMade Tour Burner Driver
    TaylorMade Burner Driver

    ReplyDelete

Lets us know what you think...